Showing EST — switch region
Price history
Beanie Buddies Auction History on eBay
1,728 past listings that closed overnight.
Prices shown are starting prices at time of collection. Final sold prices coming soon.
Past Beanie Buddies auctions on eBay
-
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Kicks Green Bear Plush Soccer Ball Patch Vintage 2000 Ages 3-7Started at $5.160 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Sunny Orange Teddy Bear Plush Vintage 2000 Ages 3+Started at $5.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Mellow Pastel Tie-Dye Teddy Bear Plush Vintage 1999 Ages 3+Started at $3.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Cure Pink Bear Plush Beanbag Vintage 2002 Ages 3-7 YearsStarted at $9.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Large Plush Beanie Buddy - BOOTIES the Cat (14 Inch) MWNMT Stuffed Animal ToyStarted at $24.990 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Babies Peace the Bear Beanie BabyStarted at $5.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie Buddy - MUM the Bear (14 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal. Nice ConditionStarted at $5.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Plush Penguin Lot for Ages 3-7 Years 3-4 4-7 YearsStarted at $30.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Scoundrel Stuffed Plush Bandana 12" Pre-owned, Excellent Cond.Started at $30.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Patriotic Beanie Buddy & Beanie Baby Lot USA America Rescue FDNY White LeftyStarted at $15.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie Buddies Snowball Snowman 12” 2001 Plush W/ Scarf Hat & Tag ProtectorStarted at $10.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Lips the Ty-Dyed Fish Large 13" 1999 Retired Plush Toy W/TagsStarted at $8.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesRetired TY BEANIE BUDDY LEFTY THE DONKEY FROM 2000 NewStarted at $9.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanies Buddy Green Holiday Teddy Bear Excellent Condition RetiredStarted at $7.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY BEANIE BUDDY - PATTI the PLATYPUS - FUCHSIA - MAGENTA - DUCKStarted at $10.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie Buddy PINCHERS! GREAT Condition With All Tags! 🔥Non-Error CHECKED🔥Started at $0.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie Buddies - JABBER - Parrot- 1999Started at $5.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie Buddies10” Ty Beanie Buddies Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal 2004 VintageStarted at $6.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Peace the Ty-Dyed Bear NEW 14" 1999 Retired Plush ToyStarted at $9.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Flitter Butterfly Plush w/ Hang Tag Vintage 1999Started at $5.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy PINEAPPLE HOME House (Spongebob Squarepants) 12" MWMTs Plush ToyStarted at $25.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Happy Hippo Purple Plush Beanbag Vintage 1993Started at $4.020 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Deuce Blue Bear Plush U.S. Open 2006 Ages 3-7 YearsStarted at $3.290 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesVintage Ty Beanie Buddy Princess Diana Bear 1998 - PE Pellets - 14" PurpleStarted at $6.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026