Showing EST — switch region
Price history
Beanie Buddies Auction History on eBay
1,728 past listings that closed overnight.
Prices shown are starting prices at time of collection. Final sold prices coming soon.
Past Beanie Buddies auctions on eBay
-
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Bubbles the Fish Very Soft 10" Long, Large . With TagsStarted at $0.990 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie Buddy Millennium Bear – Plush Purple 2000 Mint With TagsStarted at $0.990 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Gray Bunny/Rabbit Plush w/ Heart Hang Tag 1999 VintageStarted at $5.600 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Green & Yellow Duck Plush w/ Heart Hang Tag 1998 VintageStarted at $4.120 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Lucky the Ladybug 9" W/ TagsStarted at $5.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beannie Buddy Bears - ThreeStarted at $12.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies USA Bear Plush Lot Ages 3+ 3-4 Years 5-7 8-11 YearsStarted at $0.990 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie Buddies1998 princess Diana buddy bearStarted at $25.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Patriotic Teddy Bear Plush Lot of 2 Heart Tags 2001Started at $20.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Hippity Green Bunny Plush w/ Heart Swing Tag 1998 VintageStarted at $8.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie Buddiesthe beanie buddies collection CrabStarted at $77.990 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie Buddy - SPANGLE the American Bear (14 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal ToyStarted at $12.500 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Baby Powder Bear Plush 1997 Ages 3 & Up 3-11 Years Soft FluffyStarted at $8.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Praying Bear Plush Style 5601 1998 Ages 3 and Up 3-11 YearsStarted at $8.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Sizzle the Bear Vintage 2001 Retired Vibrant Red Plush 14"Started at $10.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Fuzz the Bear 1999 Corrected Tag Version Tylon Plush 13.5"Started at $10.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Groovy Pastel Bear Plush Beanbag 1998 Vintage Ages 3+Started at $3.760 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Teddy Bear Plush Lot of 4 w/ Hang Tags 1999 VintageStarted at $6.140 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie Buddy - FUZZ the Bear (13.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal ToyStarted at $20.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Buddy Teddy Green Teal Bear Stuffed Plush 2000 14"Started at $3.990 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy 9" Halloween Spinner the Spider from 1999 New With Tag ProtectorStarted at $9.990 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Lefty Gray Donkey Plush Stuffed Animal, Vintage 2000Started at $40.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Righty Gray Elephant Plush Stuffed Animal 2000 VintageStarted at $40.000 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy - Chilly the Polar Bear - Large 13" 1998 Retired Plush ToyStarted at $4.950 bids
Jul 16, 2026