Showing EST — switch region
Price history
Beanie Buddies Auction History on eBay
1,718 past listings that closed overnight.
Prices shown are starting prices at time of collection. Final sold prices coming soon.
Past Beanie Buddies auctions on eBay
-
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Nanook Beanie Buddy 1999 Rainbow 🌈 Star ⭐️ Husky DogStarted at $12.990 bids
Jul 18, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Buttons Beanie Buddy 3rd/1st Gen 1997 So Cute And AdorableStarted at $12.990 bids
Jul 18, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Congo Beanie Buddy 1999 Rainbow 🌈 Star ⭐️ Collectible And CuddlyStarted at $12.990 bids
Jul 18, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Groovy Beanie Buddy 1999 Rainbow 🌈 Star ⭐️ A Great Gift 🎁 For Any ChildStarted at $12.990 bids
Jul 18, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Clubby 3 Beanie Buddy 2000 Rainbow 🌈 Star ⭐️ Beautiful and Ready for SaleStarted at $12.990 bids
Jul 18, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies "Lips" 1999 13.5" Vivid Colorful FishStarted at $6.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie Buddies2 + Peace Bears Hanging With A Garcia Good ConditionStarted at $50.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy HOPE the PRAYING BEAR 10" Large Plush Vintage 1998 Baby RetiredStarted at $17.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Princess Diana 14-inch Purple Plush Bear with Tags 1998Started at $18.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesBeanie BUDDIES Set of five Clubby Bears - Very well preserved and all retiredStarted at $30.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Babies Lot Plush Toys with Tags Various Animals and ColorsStarted at $1.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie Buddies1998 Original TY Beanie Buddy Quackers 11" plush with tagStarted at $11.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies "2001 Holiday Teddy" 14" Vivid Green and Maroon BearStarted at $5.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesVintage 2002 TY Beanie Buddy #1 Bear Red 14" Plush Teddy Bear, Cuddling SizeStarted at $7.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Pillow Pals Collection Carrots Pink Bunny Rabbit Plush Beanbag 1998 Age 3+Started at $19.250 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTY Beanie BUDDY “Champion” 2002 FIFA World Cup SPAIN Nose FlagStarted at $1.990 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Classy Blue Bear Plush Beanie Babies Vintage 2001Started at $10.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Jumbo Valentine Red Plush Bear for Ages 3+ 3-4 4-7 8-11 YearsStarted at $200.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Tie-Dye Peace Bear Plush w/ Hang Tag Retired 1996 VintageStarted at $5.040 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie Buddiesty beanie buddy tracker the hound dog 1998 VintageStarted at $0.990 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Buddies Coral The Fish Plush 2000 Stuffed Animal Toy MWMTStarted at $11.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddies Fuzz Bear Plush Teddy 1999 Vintage Age 3+ 3-7 YearsStarted at $5.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Goose Bird Gray Black White Plush w/ Heart Hang Tag 1998 VintageStarted at $4.720 bids
Jul 17, 2026 -
EndedBeanie BuddiesTy Beanie Buddy Batty the Brown BatStarted at $25.000 bids
Jul 17, 2026