Showing EST — switch region
Price history
US eBay Tooth Fairy Pillows Auction History
44 past listings that closed overnight.
Prices shown are starting prices at time of collection. Final sold prices coming soon.
Past Tooth Fairy Pillows auctions on eBay
-
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsOwl and Squirrel Tooth Fairy PillowStarted at $3.000 bids
Jun 6, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsPillow or Pajama Cover or Tooth Fairy Pillow: 1950's era. Handmade.Started at $10.000 bids
Jun 4, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsKEEPSAKES THE TOOTH FAIRY BOX. NEW, w/o Tags. Book + Jewel Box. FREE SHIPPING!Started at $11.990 bids
Jun 4, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsUNIQUE CAT PRINT CHILD TOOTH FAIRY PILLOW HANDMADE TODDLER TEETH LOSS CONTAINERStarted at $5.000 bids
Jun 4, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsSet Of Two Tooth Fairy Holders Ceramic Hand Painted By Betty Dale Skater SkiierStarted at $17.950 bids
Jun 3, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsTooth Fairy Blue Bunny So Soft Holds Tooth In Front Pocket Back Pocket For TreatStarted at $4.990 bids
Jun 3, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsHALLMARK MUSICAL TOOTH FAIRY PILLOW. 10" WIDE. VICTORIAN HEART W/ LACE & RIBBONSStarted at $24.970 bids
Jun 1, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsNWT Vintage “Tooth Fairy” plush doll, Dreamsicles Angel Hugs, with tooth pocketStarted at $5.440 bids
Jun 1, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsTwo tooth fairy Caddy teeth Holder Handmade With SnapStarted at $5.000 bids
May 30, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsDreamsicles Angel Hugs TOOTH FAIRY Plush Stuffed Toy Doll 9”x7” Tooth PocketStarted at $4.990 bids
May 29, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsWooden Tooth Fairy Door Hanger with pink bagStarted at $10.000 bids
May 26, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsTwo tooth fairy Caddy teeth Holder Handmade With SnapStarted at $5.000 bids
May 23, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsDreamsicles Angel Hugs TOOTH FAIRY Plush Stuffed Toy Doll 9”x7” Tooth PocketStarted at $4.990 bids
May 22, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsPillow or Pajama Cover or Tooth Fairy Pillow: 1950's era. Handmade.Started at $10.000 bids
May 21, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsKEEPSAKES THE TOOTH FAIRY BOX. NEW, w/o Tags. Book + Jewel Box. FREE SHIPPING!Started at $11.990 bids
May 21, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsTooth Fairy Blue Bunny So Soft Holds Tooth In Front Pocket Back Pocket For TreatStarted at $4.990 bids
May 20, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsNEW TUG AND THE TOOTH Plush, Story Book Tooth Chart Fairy Kid tooth loss pillowStarted at $6.950 bids
May 19, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsHALLMARK MUSICAL TOOTH FAIRY PILLOW. 10" WIDE. VICTORIAN HEART W/ LACE & RIBBONSStarted at $24.970 bids
May 18, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsNWT Vintage “Tooth Fairy” plush doll, Dreamsicles Angel Hugs, with tooth pocketStarted at $5.440 bids
May 18, 2026 -
EndedTooth Fairy PillowsOwl and Squirrel Tooth Fairy PillowStarted at $3.000 bids
May 17, 2026