Showing EST — switch region
Price history
Pillow Pals Auction History on eBay
116 past listings that closed overnight.
Prices shown are starting prices at time of collection. Final sold prices coming soon.
Past Pillow Pals auctions on eBay
-
EndedPillow PalsVintage 90s TY Beanie Baby Pillow Pal Purr Tiger & Speckles Cat Leopard JaguarStarted at $20.000 bids
Jun 30, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsNorthwest WWE Seth Rollins Cloud Pillow Plush Pal Rare VintageStarted at $9.990 bids
Jun 29, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy 1998 Sherbet Tie Dye Bear Pillow Pal 14" Plush Stuffed Animal New TagsStarted at $12.990 bids
Jun 29, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTY PILLOW PALS 1998 Buddy Plush 14” Bright Yellow HUGGY The BEAR Sewn Eyes & BowStarted at $12.480 bids
Jun 29, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy Pillow Pals Collection Chewy Plush Beanbag Stuffed Animal 1999 MPN 3013Started at $13.600 bids
Jun 29, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy Pillow Pals “Antlers” The Moose Excellent Condition W/TagsStarted at $7.000 bids
Jun 28, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy Pillow Pals Push Lamb Baba Soft Toy with Tag - Style 3008 Retired 1996 - 13"Started at $7.990 bids
Jun 20, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy The Pillow Pals Collection Ribbit Frog Plush Toy 1996 Ages 3-7 Years 3-4 4-7Started at $25.000 bids
Jun 19, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsVintage TY Pillow Pals Gen 1 Snap With Tag 1994Started at $125.000 bids
Jun 19, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy Pillow Pals Collection Woof Dog Beanbag Plush Vintage Retired 1998Started at $4.500 bids
Jun 18, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsVintage TY Pillow Pals 1996 BaBa Little Lamb White Sheep NWT 13”Started at $24.990 bids
Jun 18, 2026 -
EndedPillow Pals1999 Ty Baby Pillow Pals- Lamybaby- Stuffed Plush Rattle Peach Lamb Animal w TagStarted at $20.000 bids
Jun 18, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsVintage 1999 TY Baby BunnyBaby Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Pink Blue Rattle TagStarted at $20.000 bids
Jun 18, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy Pillow Pals Collection Chewy Plush Beanbag Stuffed Animal 1999 MPN 3013Started at $3.600 bids
Jun 17, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy Pillow Pals Orca Whale 14.5 Inch Long Stuffed Toy 1997 (No Hang Tags)Started at $0.990 bids
Jun 17, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsVintage 11.5” 1999 TY DogBaby Puppy Dog Plush Baby RattleStarted at $25.000 bids
Jun 17, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy 1996 SPECKLES from the Pillow Pals CollectionStarted at $133.600 bids
Jun 16, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTY Beanie Buddy Pillow Pal Lot of 3Started at $25.000 bids
Jun 16, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsVintage 90s TY Beanie Baby Pillow Pal Purr Tiger & Speckles Cat Leopard JaguarStarted at $20.000 bids
Jun 16, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsNorthwest WWE Seth Rollins Cloud Pillow Plush Pal Rare VintageStarted at $9.990 bids
Jun 15, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy 1998 Sherbet Tie Dye Bear Pillow Pal 14" Plush Stuffed Animal New TagsStarted at $12.990 bids
Jun 15, 2026 -
EndedPillow Pals🫎 Ty Pillow Pals Green Moose “Antlers” 1999 Plush – No Tag 🧸Started at $4.000 bids
Jun 15, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTy Pillow Pals Hopper & Happily Bunny Plush Lot for Ages 3-7 Years, 3-4, 4-7Started at $1.990 bids
Jun 15, 2026 -
EndedPillow PalsTY PILLOW PALS 1998 Buddy Plush 14” Bright Yellow HUGGY The BEAR Sewn Eyes & BowStarted at $32.480 bids
Jun 15, 2026