Showing EST — switch region
Price history
Cookie Cutters Auction History on eBay
1,184 past listings that closed overnight.
Prices shown are starting prices at time of collection. Final sold prices coming soon.
Past Cookie Cutters auctions on eBay
-
EndedCookie CuttersBunnies cookie cutter Stamp Brown Bag Small recipe book Easter bunnyStarted at $12.990 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersVintage Set of 5 Orange Plastic Nesting COOKIE CUTTERS: Autumn/ HalloweenStarted at $5.450 bids
Jul 16, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersPampered Chef Rolling Cookie Cutter # 1442 & 5 Attachments Kitchen Dough RollerStarted at $4.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersChef'n Cookease Cookie Cutter And StencilStarted at $15.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersNFL Cookie Cutter Set Denver Broncos Blue Plastic Easy Grip Handle 4 ShapesStarted at $13.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersGreen Mini 3D Camel Cake Pop Plunger, Plastic, 2-Pack ThemeStarted at $10.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersCookie Cutter Lot – 2 Sets – Maple Leaves & Numbers – Baking & CraftsStarted at $2.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersWilton Easter 6 Piece Cookie Cutters 2 Bunnies Flower Egg Butterfly Tulip NEWStarted at $4.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersNEW Christmas Cookie StoryBook set - 12 cookie cutters by Celebrate ITStarted at $10.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersStar Wars Baking Collection, Cookie Cutters And Cupcake Decorations, New In BoxStarted at $17.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie Cutters6pc Cookie Cutter Set Plastic & Metal w/ Handle, Mixed ShapesStarted at $5.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersHoliday Time Linzer 7-Pc Round Metal Cookie Cutter Set, Silver HolidayStarted at $2.800 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie Cutters4 Vintage Cookie Cutters: Spade, Club, Diamond & Star are 2.5" with handleStarted at $4.350 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersGingerbread Man Boy Comfort Grip 4" Cookie Cutter by Wilton Christmas/BirthdayStarted at $3.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersHeart shaped 4" Comfort Grip Cookie Cutter by Wilton Valentine's Day /WeddingStarted at $4.500 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersPampered Chef Kids Emoji Cookie Cutters Lot Of 7 Press/Cutters Green PlasticStarted at $6.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersButterfly plastic cookie cutter, 3.5" EXCELLENT conditionStarted at $5.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersTovolo Sugar Skull Cookie Cutters Cut and Press NewStarted at $0.790 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersPME Lot Of 7 Pieces Cookie Cutter And Embosser Santa Holly ReindeerStarted at $8.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersPAMPERED CHEF Creative Cutters Set Mini Cookie Cutter Set of 7 Storage Tin 1095Started at $6.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersNEW Wilton Holiday Shapes Metal Christmas Cookie Cutter Set, 18-pieceStarted at $6.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersVintage 1997 Wilton “Treats 4 You” Baking Pans Christmas Tree Star Stocking CaneStarted at $17.990 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersBIRKMANN Merry Christmas Wood Silicone Cookie Stamp NWT GermanyStarted at $16.500 bids
Jul 15, 2026 -
EndedCookie CuttersStar Wars Cookie Cutters- Set of 4 in Box by Williams Sonoma -NewStarted at $9.000 bids
Jul 15, 2026